Join Us

Academic freedom is not a partisan issue—it is a fundamental American principle that transcends politics. The defense of institutional independence, free inquiry, and intellectual integrity requires the engagement of every Columbia alumnus and alumna who value these ideals.

Whether you graduated decades ago or recently, your voice matters. We need Columbia alumni from all backgrounds, professions, and perspectives to stand together in defense of academic freedom.

Together, we can ensure that Columbia University remains a place where free inquiry thrives, where merit determines advancement, and where academic integrity stands firm against political pressure from any administration, present or future.



Frequently Asked Questions

Who are you?
Columbia Alumni for Academic Freedom is a group of concerned alumni supporting academic freedom at Columbia University in face of the university’s $200 million settlement with the Trump administration that included terms that significantly diminished academic freedom at Columbia. In addition to paying the $200 million penalty, the university pledged, among other things, direct administrative oversight of select departments, tracking of foreign student data for review by the U.S. government, and the appointment of an independent monitor to make sure all terms are complied with.

How was CAAF started?
Columbia Alumni for Academic Freedom started as a loose affiliation of Columbia alumni who wanted to fight for the academic freedom and institutional autonomy of Columbia in the face of attacks by the Trump Administration.  Our first act was to issue an open letter imploring that Columbia not to be the first domino to fall in the federal government’s war against higher education. We have since filed amicus briefs in the Harvard case, and more recently joining the Columbia coalition to Open the Gates and to reform the Board of Trustees in a number of ways that will democratize governance so Columbia is stronger and more prepared to protect academic freedom.  Losing the initial battle with the Trump Administration has doubled our resolve to restore the autonomy of the outstanding, storied Alma Mater for which we have enduring respect and love.

Who is eligible to join?
CAAF is an alumni group.  All Columbia University alumni who have graduated and received a degree from any of the individual schools at Columbia University are eligible to join. 

Why are only alumni allowed to join?
Alumni are a powerful constituency group within the Columbia community. The university raises tens of millions of dollars every year from alumni. Many Columbia alumni are highly accomplished in their professional fields. Alumni have some leverage over university policy. The efforts of Columbia alumni who are not former U.S. presidents or CEOs benefit the school in myriad ways. For example, many alumni interview prospective students or speak highly of the university to those who want to apply. Alumni help students and other alumni by giving them access to their professional and social networks. We have an inherent stake in the value of a Columbia degree. Of vital importance is that, as a group, we have standing as a legal class. The university administration is aware of these facts. If enough of us get together to demand responsible change, they will listen.

Who are your partners?
Currently we are building a coalition with other university partners, such as the Columbia University chapter of the AAUP, student organizations and community partners.

How are you funded?
Currently we are not funded and are run by volunteers, however, we desperately need funds to scale our efforts and increase our operational capacity. 

How can I contact you directly?
Contact us at info@columbiaalumniforacademicfreedom.org with any comments or concerns you may have. We aim to reply to emails within a week.

How can I volunteer?
Please contact us at info@columbiaalumniforacademicfreedom.org to discuss volunteer needs. We need volunteers to help with organizing, fundraising, legal analysis, messaging, communications, research, and outreach to other groups on and off campus. Exactly how you can help will depend on your experience and where we need help. Let us know which of these areas interests you and what your relevant background is. Also, let us know how much time you have to help. Thank you!

What can I do now?
The most important thing you can do is join us at https://www.columbiaalumniforacademicfreedom.org/. There is strength in numbers. When the university administration knows that thousands of alumni are fighting for academic freedom, they will listen. By joining us, you will be on our email list and receive updates on the fight for academic freedom and governance reform. Tell your fellow Columbians about us and ask them to join the fight for responsible change.

How can I let the Columbia Administration know that I am unhappy?
If you would like to reach the Columbia administration or the Board of Trustees, contact information can be found on the Columbia University website.

What is governance reform?
An institution is governed by rules that can set it up for success or failure. When institutional structures create misaligned interests, poor risk management, and a lack of accountability, bad things happen. Cooper Union right here in New York City provides both a cautionary tale about flawed governance and a hopeful story about how governance reform can restore a university’s core mission. Cooper Union had been tuition free for more than 150 years, providing NYC’s working and middle classes with  high-quality engineering and fine arts education.  In 2014, following a period of reckless spending by the university president and poor oversight by its board, the school announced that tuition would no longer be free. Alumni, students, and faculty organized and this ultimately led to changes in board structure at the school.  Cooper Union is planning to once again become tuition free for the 2028-2029 academic year.

Why is governance reform so important, and why should I care? 
Three words: representation, transparency, and accountability. This is how we expect our federal, state, and local governments to operate. Similarly, many private institutions such as publicly traded companies and foundations allow stakeholders to vote for their boards, release summations of board meetings, and publish detailed benchmark results. Currently, the Columbia Board of Trustees is self-perpetuating, meaning that existing trustees are solely responsible for electing new members of the Board. Alumni, students, and faculty members have NO say in the leadership of the university. Nor is there any transparency.  The votes and minutes of Board meetings are sealed for fifty years. The Columbia community thrives or suffers based on the decisions of the Board but can’t determine its selection, and the community has no input in major decisions. We believe that stakeholder representation on the Board would be more likely to protect academic freedom at Columbia. We also believe that if alumni have a say in electing the Board, they will be more likely to be socially and financially engaged with Columbia.

What are your demands for governance reform?  
Our demands are simple: 
1. Increase the size of the Board of Trustees from 24 to 72 members. 
2. Allow alumni, faculty, and student trustees to directly elect 40 Board members. The remaining Board members will be selected by all Trustees and will be selected on the basis of their service to the Columbia community. 
3. Minutes of Board of Trustee meetings will be public. 
4.  Board of Trustees votes will also be public.

How is this reform to be done?
Alas, this is a complicated question. Columbia University is governed by a Charter and a set of By-Laws. The By-Laws can be changed by a majority vote from the Board of Trustees. A change in the By-Laws or even a simple vote by the Board could, for example, make the votes and minutes of the Board public. Increasing the number of Trustees and changing how they are selected will require amending the Charter. This can only be done by the New York State Legislature.

Who is behind the movement for governance reform? 
At Columbia, the movement is supported by CAAF (Columbia Alumni for Academic Freedom), the Columbia chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) and the Columbia College Student Council (CCSC). We expect this coalition to grow in the coming months. Nationally, there is a growing movement for democratizing university governance. The Democratize Yale movement is one of many arguing for similar reforms.

What does this have to do with academic freedom? 
Everything. Columbia University’s Board of Trustees appoints senior administrators (including the university president), approves faculty appointments, and oversees financial matters. Senior administrators play a crucial role in fostering–or suppressing–academic freedom at our alma mater. The breadth and depth of faculty appointments is the beating heart of free inquiry at Columbia. Also, maintaining the university’s financial health allows it to better withstand government attacks on academic freedom. We believe a better governance structure at Columbia may have led to a less draconian settlement or even to contesting the government’s claims against the university, as Harvard did.

What is our timetable for governance reform?
This is a difficult question and depends on multiple factors. Some reforms can be enacted by the existing Board of Trustees. If the Board is willing to make votes and minutes of Board meetings public, that can happen at the next Board meeting. Other aspects will likely be a tougher fight.  To increase the number of trustees and to change how they are elected requires an act by the New York State Legislature. We suspect that most legislators do not know this and may similarly be unaware of the importance of governance reform at a private university like Columbia. We need to begin educating and lobbying New York legislators. Most importantly, we work for governance reform across the board with persistence and focus.

How do other R1 research universities handle governance?
Public universities, including the University of California, University of Michigan, University of Wisconsin, and the State University of New York (SUNY), have governing bodies such as a Board of Regents whose members are selected by democratically elected state officials. The Board’s proceedings and votes are made public.  Private universities have a mix of governance models.  In some cases, high-ranking government officials (e.g. the state governor), are ex officio members of the Board of Trustees. Sometimes alumni, students, faculty, and even employees can be directly elected to the Board. Some examples of peer institutions that have a mix of directly elected alumni, student, and faculty trustees are Cornell, Brown, and Princeton.

Have private universities ever successfully reformed their governance structure?
Yes. In 2010 Harvard introduced its first significant governance reform since 1650 when it boosted the number of Corporation (Harvard’s Board) members to 13 from 7. In 1969, Columbia created the University Senate in response to a university-wide referendum. The new Senate included student and faculty members. 

What about civil liberties, such as free speech, free assembly, etc.?
We believe that governance reform goes hand-in-hand with civil liberties. Governance reform will allow for direct input by the Columbia community on matters of civil liberties.

How does this address issues of discrimination on campus?
Discrimination on campus is important to address and we believe that governance reform will give sidelined and marginalized voices a path to rectify their grievances. Currently, discrimination procedures are handled at the university administrative level with little transparency or input from the community. Without any say in governance, there is no way for the Columbia community to have a voice in expressing or acting upon discriminatory measures beyond what is legally required.

What is your position on threats such as ICE on campus?
Currently, the Columbia administration requires ICE to produce a judicial warrant to access dorms and other buildings, while allowing them free access to public spaces.. This does not mean that Columbia has done an adequate job of completely protecting vulnerable members of our community. We believe that Columbia should be more transparent about their policy with respect to ICE and other government activity on campus and give the community resources to fight unlawful arrests or operations on Columbia grounds.

How are you supporting students and faculty?
We are working on building a coalition for the entire Columbia community, including the AAUP, Columbia College Student Council and others, to fight for agency, transparency and accountability.  Governance reform will ensure that Columbia’s charter supports everyone on campus.

What does the future of Columbia look like?
We may not have all causes in common, but we all have a common cause: a Columbia that delivers transparency, agency and accountability to and for our entire community. Governance reform is the key to ensuring that our participation is codified not only for today, but for future generations of Columbia students.

How does Columbia’s federal settlement compare with peer institutions?
In a word, poorly. The settlement amount ($200 million) was more than twice that of Northwestern University, which had the second largest settlement at $75 million. Brown University, which signed its settlement with the Trump Administration only one week after Columbia, agreed to a $50 million payment. Brown’s settlement money goes entirely to Rhode Island state programs for worker development. Similarly, Cornell University settled for only $60 million, and only half of that goes to the U.S. Treasury. The other $30 million goes to fund agricultural research. In contrast, all of Columbia’s $200 million settlement goes to the federal government, leaving alumni wondering if their donations constitute voluntary tax payments to fund things they may vehemently oppose, such as illegal ICE detentions.

Isn’t the settlement water under the bridge?
Not yet. The terms of the Columbia settlement state that the deal expires six months before Donald Trump must leave office, leaving Columbia open to a second round of attacks.

If Harvard wins its case against the Trump Administration, will the Columbia settlement be overturned?
This is unlikely. As argued in the amicus briefs that CAAF filed in the Federal District and Appeals Courts, Columbia’s First Amendment and due process rights were violated, just as Harvard is alleging in its suit against the U.S. government; because Columbia settled, however, even if the Supreme Court ruled in Harvard’s favor, the ruling would not apply to our alma mater. One possible exception would be if Columbia could prove that it was coerced into the settlement. On the face of it, a compelling argument could be made for this, but in reality this is a very high legal hurdle to clear.

Why did Columbia University agree to such a bad settlement?
We don’t know. Unlike President Mnookin’s former employer, the University of Wisconsin, the minutes and votes of the Columbia Board of Trustees are not made public. Instead, the Board actually requires that they be sealed for 50 years.

Previous Acting President Claire Shipman said that academic freedom and institutional independence were unaffected by the settlement. Is this true?
We urge everyone to read the settlement and decide for themselves, but the consensus at CAAF is that the answer is absolutely not. Columbia agreed to place an academic department in receivership at the insistence of the U.S. government. They further agreed to change their practices for hiring academics in non-tenure track positions and agreed to monitor the social media accounts of international student applicants. Additionally, the U.S. government’s actions have undoubtedly chilled free speech on campus.  

Do the recent reports by whistle blowers in the Department of Justice suggest that allegations of antisemitism were a pretext for the authoritarian capture of American universities?
Perhaps. In August 2026, a former Department of Justice lawyer alleged “that the investigations into some of the nation’s most prestigious academic institutions were designed to strong-arm the schools into cutting deals for political purposes. Outcomes of the investigations were ‘predetermined, without regard to the evidence’ in a ‘politically mandated effort’ to extract money from schools through settlement demands and funding freezes under the pretext of rooting out antisemitism.” While we believe that the report by Columbia’s Task Force on Antisemitism presented credible examples of antisemitism, we do not believe that the U.S. government followed the procedures under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to investigate antisemitic incidents or to discipline Columbia when violations were found. 

Have Department of Justice whistleblowers shed light on the Columbia settlement?
Yes. On August 17, 2026 the Government Accountability Project, a non-profit committed to whistleblower advocacy and protection, sent an email to Congress containing the testimony of former Department of Justice (DOJ) lawyers. These attorneys included Haley Van Erem, a nine-year veteran of the department, as well as other former lawyers who are currently anonymous.  According to the letter, “[i]n the context of the Columbia investigation, M[s]. Van Erem and her colleagues observed findings of discrimination and related funding actions advancing on an accelerated timetable before adequate factual development and legal review were completed, including reliance on allegations that were unsupported, based on news reports or litigation filings, or that implicated protected First Amendment activity.” We should add that our amicus brief filings in support of Harvard similarly argued that Columbia’s constitutional due process and First Amendment rights were violated when the federal government canceled its grants.

According to the whistleblowers, what prompted the Trump Administration’s aggressive action against Columbia?
Apparently, Columbia was not the original first target. Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of Civil Rights (OCR) Associate Deputy Director Daniel Shieh explained in a meeting where Van Erem was present that “the initial plan was for Harvard to be the first example, but when negotiations broke down, officials tried to make Columbia the example.” Shieh explained, “If Columbia [doesn’t settle], nobody knows what is going to happen next. Maybe Brown[.]”

Why should we believe a whistleblower?  Couldn’t they just be a disgruntled employee who is seeking to badmouth a former employer?
Haley Van Erem worked for the Department of Justice continuously for nine years, including during the first Trump Administration. Over that period of time, she had received two Special Commendations in 2019 and 2023 as well as Distinguished Service Awards in 2019, 2022, and 2023. In 2017, she received an award for interagency work.

Do we have any insight into how hard Columbia University negotiated with the federal government?
The whistleblower complaint does not provide details about the negotiations with Columbia University, but it does hint that the university had shown willingness to surrender to the U.S. government’s demands early on.  Less than one month after the government announced that it had suspended grants worth $400 million at Columbia, the HHS Acting General Counsel Sean Keveney “told Ms. Van Erem that Columbia was close to settling.”

What did the whistleblowers think of the civil rights investigations at Columbia?
Van Erem was asked to review the “factual findings” of the HHS and Department of Education Offices of Civil Rights regarding the investigation of antisemitism at Columbia University. Her first comment noted that “I have been given limited time to review this, but I could (and think we should) look more carefully at each of these allegations if given more time. My main concern is that a lot of these paragraphs involve protected [first amendment] speech, and this document should not imply that those incidents are the basis of a Title VI violation.”  The whistleblower report goes on to say “Ms. Van Erem also identified numerous false statements, allegations of actions and protected speech that would not be considered harassing conduct under Title VI, such as participating in a protest or writing an open letter, and allegations that were framed as facts but were supported solely by publicly available litigation complaints or news articles. Such information without any investigation, corroboration, or review of the institution’s response to complaints was insufficient to form the basis of findings of Title VI violations.”